Can a Failing to Signal Charge Be Beat In Court?

In Ontario, Failing to Signal Is a Traffic Offence With a Penalty of Two Demerit Points (Five CVOR Points For Truckers) and $110 Total Fine Including Costs and Surcharge. Interestingly, Successful Prosecution Requires Proof That Another Vehicle Was Potentially Affected.
A Helpful Guide to Understanding The Law Regarding Proper Signaling As a Warning For Others Using the Road:

Car With Signal Showing Intent to Turn A common frustration for many drivers is the driver that 'forgets' to signal for turns or changes of lanes.  In addition to causing frustration, failing to signal also poses a danger to others who may be surprised by an unexpected move.  Equally annoying can be the driver that uses a signal; however, the signal is applied only at the last moment in a manner that fails to warn of a forthcoming move and instead becomes simply an indicator of what the driver is actually doing rather than a warning of what the driver is about to do.  The law on proper signaling is found within s.  142 of the Highway Traffic ActR.S.O.  1990, c.  H.8, which states:

The driver or operator of a vehicle upon a highway before turning to the left or right at any intersection or into a private road or driveway or from one lane for traffic to another lane for traffic or to leave the roadway shall first see that the movement can be made in safety, and if the operation of any other vehicle may be affected by the movement shall give a signal plainly visible to the driver or operator of the other vehicle of the intention to make the movement.

Accordingly, the law requires that the signal be used to indicate an intention rather than an action.  On another note, where the law states that a signal is required to provide indication of intentions where the intention may affect safe "operation of any other vehicle", a 'failure to signal' charge appears to require proof that another vehicle was present and may be affected; accordingly, where another vehicle must be present and thus if there is no other vehicle, there is no mandate in law to signal.  Surprisingly, the mandate to signal intention applies only to, "any other vehicle"; and apparently, without similar mandate to signal intention to pedestrians.

Summary Comment

A charge of failing to signal may be successful where it is proven that a driver of an automobile failed to signal a warning of intent to change lanes or intent to make a turn if that failure could affect the operation of any other vehicle. . The qualifying requirement that the failure to signal must affect another vehicle makes 'failing to signal' and interesting charge within the Highway Traffic Act.  Notably, the failing to signal charge applies only where another "vehicle" may be affected; and accordingly, failing to signal when a pedestrian may be affected is irrelevant (albeit it is still smart to signal for the benefit of a pedestrian).  Also notable is the requirement that, in addition to proving that the charged person failed to signal, for a successful prosecution there must also be proven that another vehicle was in the vicinity in such a way that the operation of that other vehicle was potentially affected.

DK Legal Practice fights traffic ticket charges for clients located in Oakville, Mississauga, Port Credit, Etobicoke, Streetsville, among other places!

For more information, fill out the form below to send a direct inquiry to DK Legal Practice.

Provide some context to explain the nature of your inquiry.
ATTENTION: Confidential information regarding your case must not be sent through this website.  This website is not intended as providing legal advice nor intended as a method to establish a legal-representative/client relationship.  Do not include confidential details about your case by email or phone.  Use this website form only to arrange an introduction with a DK Legal Practice representative, before taking any steps to discuss the particulars of your legal case.  Legal advice cannot be provided to you via reply email or over the phone.
DK Legal Practice

700 Dorval Drive, Suite 700
Oakville, Ontario,
L6K 3V3

P: (416) 906-6663
E: info@dklegalpractice.ca

Business Hours:

9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
9:00AM – 5:00PM
Monday:
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
Thursday:
Friday:

By appointment only.  Please call for details.

Service Area:

Oakville
Streetsville
Mississauga
Milton
Halton Hills

 

Toronto
Brampton
Burlington
Vaughan
and much more

Logo:DK Legal Practice
DK LEGAL PRACTICE

SSL Secured Trust https://dklegalpractice.ca